Welcome to 44420 Butterfield, Alexandria Bay, NY 13607 — a unique and historic 5-bedroom, 1-bathroom detached home offering 1,126 sq ft of living space on an 8,712 sq ft lot. Built in 1895, this property blends rustic charm with modern comfort, presenting a rare opportunity to own a private island home with breathtaking panoramic water views.
Spacious and Inviting Interior
Step inside to a warm and welcoming living area featuring two fireplaces, including a distinctive double-sided fireplace that serves both the interior and the outdoor deck. This special feature provides cozy warmth during cooler months and creates the perfect setting for outdoor cooking, entertaining, or simply relaxing by the water.
The thoughtfully designed layout includes five bedrooms, offering ample space for family, guests, or a home office. With its rustic character and functional design, the home delivers both comfort and versatility for island living.
Waterfront Access and Boating Amenities
Living on a private island comes with exceptional water access. The property includes:
A full-size dock plus additional docking space
Two boats: a 15-foot Yamaha 40HP motorboat and a 12-foot Nissan 9.5HP motorboat
A 6HP Johnson outboard motor for additional use
Whether you enjoy boating, fishing, or simply unwinding by the water, this property makes it easy to embrace the waterfront lifestyle.
Fully Furnished and Move-In Ready
Offered fully furnished, the home also includes tools, work equipment, a chainsaw, and other essentials—everything you need to start enjoying island life immediately. This turnkey setup ensures a seamless transition for buyers seeking a private retreat or year-round residence.
Historic Charm Meets Modern Convenience
Originally built in 1895, the home maintains its historic appeal while offering modern-day functionality. Its rustic style, panoramic lake views, and unique island setting make it a truly one-of-a-kind property in the Alexandria Bay area.
Pricing and Value
The home is currently listed at $339,000, with a Zestimate of $313,600 (ranging from $298,000 to $329,000), or approximately $301 per square foot. It is assessed at $77,500, with annual property taxes of about $1,819—making it an attractive and affordable waterfront investment.
Prime Private Island Location
Enjoy the privacy and tranquility of island living while remaining close to the amenities of Alexandria Bay. This location offers the perfect balance of seclusion and convenience, ideal for boating enthusiasts, nature lovers, or anyone seeking a peaceful lakeside escape.
Final Thoughts
44420 Butterfield is a rare opportunity to own a historic, fully furnished waterfront home on a private island. With five bedrooms, a unique double-sided fireplace, panoramic views, dock access, included boats, and a fully equipped setup, this property is ideal as a year-round residence, seasonal getaway, or investment opportunity.
For more information or to schedule a viewing, please contact the listing agent via the Zillow link below the photos. Don’t miss your chance to experience island living at its finest in one of New York’s most scenic locations.
